Per the title, this post is fairly long and contains a number of images.

Following on from my earlier thread, and prompted by a few of the comments, I did a comparison using the same camera body, but with the non-L kit glass. I’m not generally a fan of pixel-peeping as images should be taken as a whole, and I’m sure most either don’t care or will be saying “duh” to most of this, but again I found it interesting to quantify visually.

In my case the kit lens is the 18-150 f3.5-6.3 STM. Actually a good little lens, APS-C only though otherwise it’d be a good FF walk-about range. I got it plus the 50mm 1.8 as a kit, and I think the kit at the time was only a little more than the body alone (an extra 200 AUD if my memory serves?). That puts the combo within spitting distance of the same money as the phone, actually a fair bit below based on current flagship prices… don’t get me started haha.

I’m not going to rehash my earlier comments, except to repeat that the intention isn’t to rubbish one or the other, I’m just comparing the two with a couple of basic tests.


First up again, the S23 Ultra.

I don’t know how to force it to use one camera over the other, but I assume that using the 10x zoom for example will use that lens/sensor combo at its native res.

Here’s the reference shot - a 1:1 crop from the middle of the pic, 12MP at 1x zoom. EXIF says 6mm (apparently 24mm FF equiv), f/1.7, ISO 10. I’m assuming then this is the 200MP camera in pixel binning mode.

A 1:1 crop at 12MP 10x (27mm, f/4.9, ISO 50):

A 1:1 crop at 12MP 100x (27mm, f/4.9, ISO 50):

And the full-but-resized version of the 100x shot for reference:

A 1:1 crop of the 50MP 1x (6mm, f/1.7, ISO 10):

I did take a 200MP image as well but the bird took off before I hit the button, if someone is really keen I can post the 1:1 crop of that too but it’s just an empty power line :)


Right, now the R7 + kit lens.

1:1 crop at 18mm f/5.6 ISO 100:

And 1:1 crop at 150mm f/6.3 ISO 125:


To be fair, telephoto isn’t really playing to the phone’s design brief. It can do it, in the same way that I can play tennis.

To that end I did also take a bunch of pictures of a drain cover that was on the footpath just ahead of me, so probably 1.5-2m away from the sensor. And as expected the phone does far better.

A 1:1 crop at 12MP 1x:

At 12MP 10x, still pretty good:

And at 12MP 100x, unsurprisingly very crunchy:


For comparison, the R7 with kit lens. ISO crept up (4000-6400) as they were in the shade and I just left it at the 1/1000 I had been using earlier:

18mm f/11:

And 150mm f/11:


And just out of interest, the 70-200L at 200mm f/11:

And with the TC attached at 400mm f/11:


The phone holds up well at modest focal lengths, but as should be expected it struggles at longer lengths/bigger zooms.

The fact the phone can take calls, play games etc plus be light and fit into a pocket while also taking an objectively pretty decent photo in most sane scenarios is genuinely impressive.

But, luckily for most of us on here, a dedicated camera and ‘real’ glass is still 100% worthwhile.

  • dual_sport_dork 🐧🗡️@lemmy.worldM
    link
    fedilink
    arrow-up
    2
    ·
    17 hours ago

    Your phone is also visibly applying a ridiculous amount of postprocessing to that image to make it appear “smoother,” applying a layer of paper mâché over the shortcomings inherent to its tiny pinhole lens and sand grain sized sensor that you probably can’t turn off.

    Let it not be said that I will ever deride somebody just for taking a photo with their phone, because I’ve certainly taken plenty in my life. Not even just because my phone was all I had to hand but even on purpose. And employing heroic amounts of effort to do so without the final result being crap.

    I only take exception to the occasional type of blissninny who regularly feels compelled to spout off in the comments that cell phone cameras are “just as good” as our big expensive pointless cameras for applications where the bringing more than one brain cell to bear on the topic would make it glaringly apparent that they absolutely are not, e.g. long range wildlife photography. The strides cell phone cameras have taken over the years are indeed impressive, but they still cannot violate the laws of physics no matter how glossy Apple or Samsung’s marketing materials are.

  • Tanis Nikana@lemmy.world
    link
    fedilink
    arrow-up
    13
    ·
    2 days ago

    Where I’m at is this: the best camera is the one that’s drawn and ready in the critical moment. If that’s my production camera, excellent, I’ll shoot with that. When I’m shooting still life or a massive urban landscape, it’s my go-to.

    However, in places where my production camera is banned, like concert venues, or simply not on my person (I’m getting food and holy crap look at that bird!) then whatever camera I have is the best camera.

    And there is no shame in this.

    • postnataldrip@lemmy.worldOP
      link
      fedilink
      arrow-up
      4
      ·
      2 days ago

      Yep agreed completely, that’s my stance too. Unless I’m specifically out to take pictures the camera will most likely be at home, and the phone does a good enough job most of the time.

      This was more about addressing the comments that pop up occasionally (whether or be here, somewhere else, in person, whatever) suggesting that phone cameras are so good now that there’s hardly any difference, why would I get a camera etc. Not to shit on the phone, more to point out that there is a difference.

      Whether the difference matters will depend on the person, the subject, the situation, and yes, what they have with them.

      I enjoy photography and if seeing that difference encourages someone to give it a proper go then that’s fantastic. And if they’re still happy with their phone, then good on them, and they can save a heap of money!

  • sbird@retrofed.com
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    3
    ·
    2 days ago

    The fact that smartphones, and therefore smartphone cameras, have become so ubiquitous has made photography so accessible to the masses, and that is something to celebrate :D

    Of course, I will always appreciate “proper” cameras, they are usually more versatile (especially if you have an interchangeable lens camera), the sensors are much larger (even M43 is significantly bigger than most smartphone sensors), the option for much nicer glass, and it’s also just more fun to shoot with something that doesn’t distract you with notifications and pings. Plus, “real” cameras still have easily swappable batteries and memory card slots, which most* smartphones no longer have.

    Smartphones are great, but they will never replace dedicated cameras in quality and versatility! Likewise, a dedicated camera cannot replace the convenience of a smartphone. Both do very well at what they do best and I think both should continue to exist :>

    *they did in the past, but not anymore for the most part. Note that Fairphone, Jolla Phone, and a few others still have both though!

  • banana_pie@piefed.zip
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    2
    ·
    2 days ago

    Thank you! Very good results. To me it seems like you could get quite good results with agressive cropping, but currently cameras really arent geared towards that use. I like my RX100 as a portable picture taker, but ease of use of smartphone is also appealing.