

You’re right in saying that my last paragraph sounds like an exaggeration, I mistakenly repeated metacritic when I meant reviewers in general. Fixed :)
I still think there’s something odd with the system as a whole if one hundred and fifty critics mostly agree on a “100/100” score. Like, this means that 99% of them never got bored, never didn’t like a mission, never felt the story dragged for a bit more, never found flaws in any of the characters.
How much of the game they played, I wonder? Because look at GTA V: roughly a 97 on Metacritic. A game that, by all accounts, surprised us all with a strong introduction… only to be met by weak character stories and awful narrative pacing. It feels like they’re voting on the technical feat, more than anything.


I guess I’ve never been enough of a fan of rockstar’s sandboxes to see it that way. Still, you make a good point :) I’ve recently realized there seems to be a lot of pure hatred for GTAVI as a concept more than anything else on lemmy/piefed, which isn’t my type of thing - I wanted to merely provide a different point of view from the fomo and hype which can be a little extra when it comes to this company’s games. I’m sure the game is good and fun at the end of the day. I hope they don’t start doing mass layoffs once again, though.